The Yelling Goat in Lancaster

205 Central Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086-1806, Lancaster

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
  • Pub
  • Vegetarian Friendly
Features
  • Takeout
  • Reservations
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Parking Available
  • Television
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Full Bar
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Bar scene
  • Families witd children
  • Kids
  • Large groups

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Do they take American Express

Yes i believe they do

Is it just me or do they never answer the phone?

Ahron, We experienced a mechanical failure on Saturday, which made us close the Restaurant at peak dinner time. Unable to get a HVAC repair company to repair the situation until Monday, December 3rd, we had to remain closed for business on Sunday as well. I apologize for not answering the phone but this was an unfortunate and unplanned event. Hopefully that explains the "unanswered" phone. Regards, Laurie

Do you serve fish frys

Yes, every Friday. Also, on Wednesday's during lent.

Do u serve soup

Yes, they do. Excellent soup at that.

Do you have patio dining on Tuesday evenings? What hours?

Unfortunately, we are closed until Friday. We are doing an overhaul "clean/sterilization" of the Restaurant. We will be offering take-out and patio dining again on Friday, Saturday and Sunday. We will be closed on Monday and finally, Tuesday June 16th we will be running full-steam. We will have our patio as well as inside seating. We will also be doing take-out. A full list of hours and our menu is on our facebook page. Hope to see you soon. Laurie (owner)

What comes with fish fry

Susie, Our fish (cod) can be broiled, beer-battered or served cajun style. It comes with home-made macaroni salad, french fries, coleslaw and rye bread. We serve it every Friday, lunch and dinner. We also serve it on Wednesday's during lent. We strongly recommend dinner reservations, especially on the Weekends as we typically "sell-out." Thanks for the inquiry. Best Regards, Laurie

Is the patio open yet

Yes

Do they have a dog friendly patio?

Yes it is dog friendly

Review

Add rating restaurant:
The Yelling Goat
MB
Maria B.
google
05.01.2024
5/5

Great food and service. 👌

The Yelling Goat
NL
Natalie L
google
09.14.2018
4/5

Extensive food and beer list. The menu is a little disjointed and rather lengthy, but I've ate here a few times and each time the food was delicious. Prices are reasonable. Nice atmosphere inside. Service was a little slow although this place has never been busy when I was there. There are renovations happening on the site and I think they might have a patio upstairs.

The Yelling Goat
JK
Jess K.
google
09.12.2018
5/5

Went to dinner here for the first time tonight and I was not disappointed!! Was beautiful sitting on the patio on!! The menu all sounds AMAZING!! It was so hard to choose what to order which makes me want to go back to try even more!! The bread with the balsamic was yummy! I got the goat burger special and it was amazing!! We will be back!

The Yelling Goat
JS
Joe Szafranski
google
08.05.2018
5/5

Awesome food, so stuffed! Bang for your buck!

The Yelling Goat
KO
Karen Okonowski-Dunlap
google
07.12.2018
5/5

The place looks great since the fire, food is outstanding and just as expected. I wish the wine selection was more extensive but I can enjoy hard ciders too.Welcome back.

The Yelling Goat
SC
Scott Chouinard
google
06.20.2018
5/5

The bread is AMMMMMAZING! Nice atmosphere... We sat at the bar and the bartender was very pleasant... Great service! Thank you

The Yelling Goat
KO
KC Olson
google
06.18.2018
5/5

We had a large family gathering to celebrate my Dad's 87th birthday, our waitresses were great, took care of us very well. Food and drink selections are vast, great place to gather and eat!

The Yelling Goat
JP
Jan Proy
google
06.13.2018
3/5

The duck breast was perfect & delish. Brussel sprouts were cold & over cooked. Duck sauce w/wings was excellent. Super beer selection. Calzone good but too much dough. Noise level off the charts.

The Yelling Goat
MS
Michele Sobowiec
google
06.10.2018
5/5

The "Yelling Goat" was a lot of fun! Very nice establishment with very nice employees! Our server, Andre, was wonderful and the bartender was welcoming! The hamburgers we ordered were extraordinary! Truly, a sight to behold. Can not wait to return to try other items on the menu! See you soon 😘

The Yelling Goat
tm
ted mighells
google
04.24.2018
5/5

customer service at it's finest. we arrived late on a Saturday night and just wanted to go to the bar to drink and possibly eat. The place was packed. We were advised that we should have made reservations. The owner came over and said that he would accommodate us. We must have had two different bartenders and wait staff checking on us and keeping us updated. We ended up sitting at a table instead of the bar. (our choice) The long Island iced teas are amazing. I had the steak steak steak calzone. the thing is huge. it was very good. The marinara sauce was hands down the best I've ever had. My wife had the Fig Gorgonzola and Caramelized Walnuts pizza It had Sun Dried Mission Figs, Gorgonzola, Truffle Oil and Mozzarella. It was delicious. This place is highly recommended!! I also tried the meatball. they were homemade and delicious.

The Yelling Goat
KL
Kevin Leigh
google
04.21.2018
2/5

Sorry Tina. I removed my 5 star rating because I think the pork chop on the menu should be removed until you fix the recipe. It’s a greasy mess. Normally the food is fantastic and my wife’s was delicious. We will be back but fix that thin breaded burnt mess with goo on top that you call a pork chop. See the grease on my plate in the picture.

The Yelling Goat
JD
Josh Dix
google
03.24.2018
5/5

I got the steak salad with horse radish sauce and it was excellent. I ordered it gluten free and did not get sick. They seem to be pretty gluten allergy aware :).

The Yelling Goat
JU
Jill Ungaro
google
03.22.2018
5/5

Great service, great food and great atmosphere. Can’t go wrong here

The Yelling Goat
CN
Casey Newton
google
02.23.2018
5/5

Everything was amazing. Duck seems to be a specialty, and they really seem to know what they're doing. Everything was cooked perfectly. The restaurant is attractively decorated. Equally nice for a fancy night out or a more casual dinner.

The Yelling Goat
Ben
google
01.21.2018
2/5

Went here a few days ago, only because I had a gift card to go there. I originally went in only to walk out before ordering after seeing the prices and the low-energy staff. The prices are outrageous (for me to say that is surprising because I am not cheap), and the portions are mixed. The roast beef dinner is $16, and left me feeling hungry. Avoid this place and go somewhere where you can get your money’s worth.

The Yelling Goat
AS
Ann Sievenpiper
google
11.15.2017
5/5

Huge menu and great food. Burgers are 12 oz..and have some interesting options. Including two stuffed varieties. 2 pages of interesting pizza offerings. Gluten free pasta offering available. Don't miss the extensive list of wing sauces and note...there's pork belly by the pound!! Good cocktail menu as well as lemonade and rootbeer for those not planning to drink.

The Yelling Goat
Sg
Shineon gamer z Malec
google
11.12.2017
5/5

Love love love this place! One of my favorite places to dine at! Adam was requested by my family for a birthday celebration a few weeks ago and he is a 5 star server! He is hilarious and definitely knows how to entertain! My In-Laws come here nearly every week and now I know why!! The menu does not disappoint at all! Everything I’ve had is so dang delicious! I highly recommend trying this family hidden gem because you will not be disappointed. :)

The Yelling Goat
Foxyting
google
11.06.2017
5/5

The food was amazing the chicken was so good I love how the place has older looking things the only thing that would be cool is a pool table and other games but it was amazing.

The Yelling Goat
DL
Diane Lovullo
google
10.24.2017
5/5

Food was delicious! Their pizzas were amazing. Allison, our waitress, was so great! Will definitely be back!!

The Yelling Goat
KS
Karen Sever
google
09.22.2017
5/5

Went for dinner with the girls!! Never been here and now we Love this place!! Good prices and Great food!! Best calzone I've ever had!!!!

The Yelling Goat
pm
pam mroz
google
08.20.2017
4/5

Food was good, drinks were tasty. I worked in that building back in the 90s when it was a dive bar. They have really done a great job fixing the place up. I gave 4 stars as the patio was full and we sat at the bar having cocktails and waiting for food as more people started streaming in. There was not bar stools removed, nor no one seemed to be keeping a head count. My friend and I haven't been inside a restaurant since March and felt uneasy as more people started sitting closer and closer to us. We retreated to a small table against a wall trying to keep a safe distance. We began to think that perhaps it was too soon for us to go inside a restaurant for us to be comfortable.

The Yelling Goat
AV
A Very Brady Clubhouse
google
07.09.2017
5/5

This place was cute, adorable and fabulous.. great view, and the stuff peppers were to die 4.....

The Yelling Goat
SD
Scott DeCota
google
06.27.2017
4/5

Great food. Expansive menu. Had a great meal work all our kids.

The Yelling Goat
A.
Aimee .F
google
06.22.2017
5/5

Excellent artichoke and spinach dip. Had a small issue with our food but Manager went way out of her way to fix it. We will definitely back to try their dinner menu !

The Yelling Goat
LB
Linton Bentsly
google
05.02.2017
5/5

THE GOAT YELLS. ITS CRIES OUT TO ME. great food and service! THE GOAT YELLLLSSSS.

The Yelling Goat
PH
Patricia Hall
google
04.15.2017
5/5

Ordered tonight for takeout. Got a prime rib and a burger. Everything was great. Plus, a great beer suggestion.

The Yelling Goat
RM
Roseanna M Paolucci
google
04.05.2017
5/5

Service was great , food was excellent, nice atmosphere. Clean and friendly. All you could want when out with a friend .

The Yelling Goat
HR
Heather Rose
google
04.02.2017
5/5

Really great food + awesome beer selection!

The Yelling Goat
MC
Mary C. St. Mary
google
03.25.2017
5/5

Fantastic food, great selection of craft beer and excellent service, plus a dog friendly patio!

The Yelling Goat
PW
Patrick Williams
google
03.21.2017
5/5

I came here for dinner with my girlfriend, and we both were very pleased! The environment is clean and decorative, the atmosphere is inviting, and the staff are friendly! I had a Bacon & Egg Burger w/ Fries, which was HUGE, and very good! She had an order of Bourbon BBQ Wings, which were also very tasty! 5 stars from us!

The Yelling Goat
MP
Mike Pennell
google
03.12.2017
5/5

Had the cheese tortellini and thought it was amazing. Service was friendly and overall had a great experience. Definitely going back

The Yelling Goat
rj
rita jenkins
google
03.01.2017
5/5

Delicious food, extensive beer list, great service. Great experience.

The Yelling Goat
AC
Andrew Conine
google
02.25.2017
4/5

Deep fried pork belly! Need I say more.

The Yelling Goat
ap
anthony prizzia
google
02.22.2017
5/5

What a place!!! The most fantastic food, staff, and of course wine.... They have something on the menu for the whole family. If you are anywhere near this place, stop what you are doing and go there.

The Yelling Goat
LP
Laurie P
google
02.18.2017
5/5

Wonderful Food!! Service was Excellent!! HUGE portion sizes. Best steak i’ve ever had-probably #BestSteakInBuffalo. We will definitely be coming back here. We had the Chicken Fingers-Mild: Amazing!! Also had Steak, French Fries, and Mushrooms-Amazing!! Lastly, for our appetizer we had Bavarian Pretzels. Loved this place.

The Yelling Goat
SJ
Steve John
google
02.07.2017
5/5

Very cool and clean atmosphere. Friendly quick service. Just had drafts and pretzels which were very good. Drooled over amazing looking Pizza and Wings being delivered to a nearby table.

The Yelling Goat
JR
Jacob Reid
google
11.17.2016
4/5

lots of interesting items to try. all been very good so far. they no longer do bread pudding though (

The Yelling Goat
xRev74
google
11.06.2016
4/5

Good food. DEFINITELY need a better process for people picking up takeout orders. Would second guess coming back just for this reason.

The Yelling Goat
DC
Dawn Cochran
google
10.25.2016
5/5

This place definitely caught me off guard. Absolutely must go here. The food was amazing. The menu was great, not just your ordinary burger with fries. The staff was great. I didn't expect the restaurant to be as big as it was. We didn't have any drinks but the bar looked fully staffed and they had posters about different brewery events.

The Yelling Goat
ZG
Zozo G. Nix
google
09.13.2016
5/5

Amazing staff, cute knick-knacks all over and a very warm atmosphere. Loved the new experience of trying their Berebere sauce.

The Yelling Goat
HC
Henry Cossitt
google
06.18.2016
4/5

It's a really nice place. There are a great many options on their menu, and their beer selection is quite impressive!

The Yelling Goat
JZ
Jill Zolnowski
google
05.06.2016
5/5

Pet friendly patio is awesome. Service and food were both great!

The Yelling Goat
EM
Electronic Merchant Systems
google
04.25.2016
5/5

Absolutely amazing service with extensive drink, food and beer menu. Definitely recommend.

The Yelling Goat
PM
Pat Maloney
google
04.04.2016
5/5

Im pretty sure John & his entourage are Gods heavenly chefs

The Yelling Goat
AP
Amanda Pienkowski
google
03.18.2016
5/5

Absolutely loved the atmosphere of this place. The menu is huge and food and service was amazing. We loved it and can't wait to go back. Tip: If you're going on a Saturday, make a reservations a day or two prior, they get slammed.

The Yelling Goat
MP
Michael Pierce
google
03.10.2016
5/5

Was there to celebrate my Birthday with my wife, daughter and son-in-law. It was my first time there. Was not disappointed...it was great! Will be coming back again soon.

The Yelling Goat
KM
Katie McCarthy
google
01.26.2016
5/5

Amazing overall experience. The bartender (Mitch) is on top of the craft beer and is very attentive; Shannon and Christina take care of every beer and food pairing and no one has a problem because they are so good, and; the be food is delicious (soup, salad, appetizer, entrees and dessert) thanks to John, Laurie and their amazing staff.

The Yelling Goat
JG
Jeff Goodwin
google
01.17.2016
5/5

First time and quite impressed. Friday reservation at 7 and table was ready on time. Great server. Food excellent. Drinks served large and not in tiny glasses half full.

The Yelling Goat
SG
Sean Grohman
google
01.15.2016
5/5

While at a soccer game, we made reservations for 7:30. We showed up at about 7:15 to a near packed house and were escorted right to our table. Megan was an outstanding server and we were in want of nothing. She was always checking to see if we needed anything. Actually, my wife mentioned how friendly everyone was. The menu was full of lots of options. The food was delicious! We're putting the Yelling Goat on our favorites list. We can't wait until were in the area again for our next visit. Great job, Yelling Goat!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17166830462

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!